• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

  • About
    • About us
    • Why SeedTime?
    • Our Beliefs
    • The Story of SeedTime
  • Podcast
  • Free Book
    • Get your 1st copy free (+S&H)
    • Order multiple copies here
  • Programs
    • Login
    • Mission-Driven Millionaire
    • True Financial Freedom
    • The Real Money Method (unbudgeting) course
    • The 10x Investing course
  • Churches
  • Blog
    • The 14 Financial Tools We Actually Use
    • Our strategy for giving away millions
    • 5 Bible Verses You Should Know (Free PDF)
    • 25 Ways to Save Money
    • Why we began giving our age as a percentage
    • My Checklist To Financial Freedom (Free PDF)
    • Tithing: an honest look and what we do
    • Why I took a Sabbatical YEAR (and how I did it)
    • How to travel for FREE [161 hotel nights and 103 flights all free]
    • 4 Financial Lessons from Solomon: The Richest Man Ever
    • How to become a millionaire by turning $2k into $1 mil
    • How to get out of credit card debt (Free PDF)
    • How I made $2,145 Last Month by decluttering
    • How I Broke Free From the Rat Race (in less than 2 years)
    • We just checked off the biggest goal in our life
    • Our Honest Medi-Share Review after 14 years
    • 4 Money Habits To Start (that basically guarantee financial success)
  • Email

Fundrise vs. Rental Property

written by Bob Lotich, CEPF® | Investing

(The following is a transcription from a video I recorded. Please excuse any typos or errors.
This is a testimonial in partnership with Fundrise. We earn a commission from partner links on SeedTime.com. All opinions are my own.)

alternative ways to invest in real estate

This article will help you decide if you should invest in Fundrise.

And I’m going to tell you about my experience with Fundrise. I will compare the numbers of my Fundrise earnings versus my actual physical rental property earnings. You’ll get a ballpark for how the two compare and then you can make your own decision.

As we’re going through this, if you have any comments or questions about this, and about my experience, definitely leave them down in the comment section down below. I will get back to you and answer you as soon as possible.

I would love to make that comment section a good resource for other people who are investigating Fundrise and trying to figure out if it’s actually a good investment.

If you prefer to watch our YouTube video about this very subject, you can view it here:

Before we dive into my current earnings with Fundrise and comparing them to a rental property, let me step back just a little bit.

Our Rental Property

In 2015, we lived in St. Louis and we moved to Nashville. We kept our old house in St. Louis, and we turned it into a rental property. And that was my first stab at having a rental property and trying to see if we could earn some passive income from doing that.

Because I wanted it to be passive, we hired a property manager who took 10% of all the monthly rents. That way I was able to completely step out of it. I didn’t have to deal with phone call in the middle of the night when the plumbing broke or any of that stuff. Our property manager took care of all that for us.

He took care of finding a good tenant, which he actually did. Did a great job. Found somebody who paid every single month and all was really good with that. And it was super passive and it was really convenient.

Our Earnings

From 2015 to 2017, we had that rental property there. And in 2017, I decided, I should actually calculate the returns and see what we’re actually earning from this property. The amount of cash we have invested in it, see what the actual return is. It took some time to add everything up and figuring out: what the total expenses were, what the income was, kind of getting that and then figuring out our actual return.

After I calculated it all up, I determined that our earnings were about 5.4% on the cash that we had invested into the property. Now, somehow in my mind, I had been thinking that we were earning about 10% on our cash invested and it must be because there were more expenses. I’m not really sure why, but I was just way off.

We were actually only earning 5.4% on that investment. Obviously we didn’t pick this rental property because it was one of the best earning ones. It was because it was the easiest. It was our property we already owned. It was easy to just transfer it into a rental property. And I do know that we could have bought another property that could have had a higher ROI, but this is what we had and this is what we started with and this is what we were earning.

Fundrise

Now in the middle of 2017, I decided to open a Fundrise account and just out of curiosity and I wanted to take the rent payments that I was getting and I would just start reinvesting the rent payments into Fundrise.

Once I had enough to buy another property, I would do that. When I opened my Fundrise account, I believe I needed to have $10,000 in order to open the account. And they’ve since lowered that to $10, I think.

And as you would expect from one of these new financial startups, the account opening process was super easy, super quick and it was just a really, really good experience, just opening the account. And honestly just getting started investing with them was really easy. 

Investing Options and Earnings

I don’t know exactly what I was thinking in terms of earnings from Fundrise when I signed up. Really, I was just trying to reinvest some of the money that was coming from my rental property, but they pay out every quarter. And as these payments started coming in and it’s like, oh, this is kind of fun. We’re actually earning some money here.

Fundrise Investment Options

I should also note that Fundrise has three different investment options that you can choose from. They have the supplemental income, which is kind of the lower risk one, then the balanced investing, which is the middle risk and then the longterm growth, which is a little bit of the higher risk one. And I opted for the balanced investing option with mine.

compare fundrise plans

Here’s a look at their projected returns for the balanced investing option. As you can see, this is way better than my rental property was. I decided to actually calculate the returns that I was getting from Fundrise. And so once I went back and actually ran the numbers on this, I actually found that my earnings from the dividends only with Fundrise was 6%, 6.0% versus the 5.4% on my rental property.

Consideration Of Appreciation

In both of those scenarios, appreciation is not really taken into consideration. But my hunch is, the appreciation for a lot of the properties that Fundrise is investing in is actually going to be considerably better than my property and the location that our property was on.

Changing Investment Options

Additionally, I should add that with Fundrise I can always change my investment option over to the higher risk one and higher reward one. And in theory, increase earnings even higher.

Once I discovered this and saw the simplicity of Fundrise, I realized how much easier it is then having our rental property and all the work that comes with that.

Because what I didn’t realize, being a new property owner, is that even with a property manager who takes care of almost everything, there’s still stuff that comes up. There’s still things that I had to deal with, taxes and there’s having to have a separate LLC to house it. And just a lot of just random things that come up, and that it’s just something I don’t have to think about with Fundrise.

Our Real Estate Investment Focus

Long story short, we have sold off our rental property and we now use Fundrise as our primary means of investing in real estate.

For us, I probably will get back into physical real estate at some point. But for right now, the simplicity of using Fundrise is just really attractive to me. And so that’s why we’re focused on that.

It’s just a great way for people who want to get started investing in real estate, but don’t want to take on the huge risk of actually buying a property and dealing with all the stuff that comes with that.

Like I said before, if you have any questions about Fundrise that you think I can answer, I’m happy to answer down in the comments and you can definitely check out their website and find a whole lot more.

Related posts:

  1. The only credit card I use for my business
  2. How to use ChatGPT for Bible study (4 ways)
  3. Hiding purchases from your spouse? [Read this]
  4. How to Pick Mutual Funds Like the Pros

About Bob Lotich, CEPF®

Bob Lotich, CEPF® is a Certified Educator in Personal Finance and has over 15+ years experience writing about Biblical personal finance. He is the award-winning author of Simple Money, Rich Life and has been named a top 20 social influencer in personal finance. Check out his on-demand Christian financial class for couples, small groups and churches called True Financial Freedom.

IFCFH Book of the Year
"The best combination of personal finance and the Christian faith that I’ve read"
– James T. (SMRL reviewer)

In this biblically sound and grace-filled money book, you'll discover the NEW rules of money that will transform your financial life. Say goodbye to outdated advice and hello to a simple, automated system that helps you achieve better results with less time and effort.

"The best combination of personal finance and the Christian faith that I’ve read"
Learn more
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Primary Sidebar

Bob Lotich

Hi there! We are Bob & Linda Lotich. Jesus followers, authors, podcasters, and undying fans of Michael Scott.

This site contains the lessons we learned on our journey from being stingy, debt-ridden fools, to being able to reach our biggest financial goal of giving $1 million by age 40, having zero debt & a paid off house by age 31, and peace with money in the process.

Now we share our best lessons with people like you, groups, and churches with our Award-winning book Simple Money, Rich Life and our 6-week video course True Financial Freedom.

Grab our book!

Simple Money Rich Life

Legal Disclaimer

The articles on this site should not be taken as financial advice. Please contact a financial advisor (or coach) for specific advice regarding your situation. Any references to interest rates, giveaways, deals, products, and websites are subject to change without notice. We try our best to keep the information current, but things are always changing so it may be different now than when it was first published. Also, all the pages on SeedTime help us pay the bills by using affiliate relationships with Amazon, Google, eBay and others but our opinions are NEVER for sale. Find out more here.

Footer



SeedTime is a 2x Plutus award winning website.
seedtime money logo



SeedTime BBB Business Review
seedtime instagram seedtime money youtube channel seedtime money twitter with Bob Lotich


Our book Simple Money, Rich Life was named 2022 book of the year!
  • Home
  • About
  • Beliefs
  • Blog
  • Courses
  • Churches
  • Press
  • Shop
  • Affiliates
  • Login

Privacy Policy | Terms | Reviews | Earnings Disclaimer | Contact | 636-344-0438
625 Bakers Bridge Ave Suite 105-134 Franklin, TN 37067
©2007-2025 · SeedTime (Formerly ChristianPF)