• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

  • About
    • About us
    • Why SeedTime?
    • Our Beliefs
    • The Story of SeedTime
  • Podcast
  • Free Book
    • Get your 1st copy free (+S&H)
    • Order multiple copies here
  • Programs
    • Login
    • Mission-Driven Millionaire
    • True Financial Freedom
    • The Real Money Method (unbudgeting) course
    • The 10x Investing course
  • Churches
  • Blog
    • The 14 Financial Tools We Actually Use
    • Our strategy for giving away millions
    • 5 Bible Verses You Should Know (Free PDF)
    • 25 Ways to Save Money
    • Why we began giving our age as a percentage
    • My Checklist To Financial Freedom (Free PDF)
    • Tithing: an honest look and what we do
    • Why I took a Sabbatical YEAR (and how I did it)
    • How to travel for FREE [161 hotel nights and 103 flights all free]
    • 4 Financial Lessons from Solomon: The Richest Man Ever
    • How to become a millionaire by turning $2k into $1 mil
    • How to get out of credit card debt (Free PDF)
    • How I made $2,145 Last Month by decluttering
    • How I Broke Free From the Rat Race (in less than 2 years)
    • We just checked off the biggest goal in our life
    • Our Honest Medi-Share Review after 14 years
    • 4 Money Habits To Start (that basically guarantee financial success)
  • Email

Budgeting is like baking cookies

written by Bob Lotich, CEPF® | Budgeting, Managing Money

budgeting is like baking cookies

For some reason the word “budget” has an interesting effect on most people causing them to cringe in pain more than the thought of going to the dentist. It really shouldn’t be as painful as people make it seem. If done correctly, it should give you MORE freedom to get what you want. If you think of a budget as a plan “that takes away all the fun” or eliminates your ability to get things you want, then you are doing it wrong.

A budget is no more than “measured spending.” I think it is a lot like baking cookies. Just like cookies, to make the perfect batch you have to follow a recipe and measure each ingredient. Of course you can improvise a little bit, but each slight variation changes the outcome of the cookies and can take a great recipe and make it mediocre, or a decent recipe and make it great.

Budgeting is not like cookies without sugar

Most people seem to think of budgeting as baking cookies without sugar or chocolate chips. To me chocolate chip cookies are the only kind, so if they don’t have chocolate chips, they aren’t really cookies.

A budget is no different, if you don’t have money budgeted for areas like going to the movies, vacation, buying clothes, or even “blow money” then IT IS like baking cookies without chocolate chips or sugar!! Of course no one likes it!! Who would eat cookies without sugar or chocolate chips?

On the other hand, if your cookies are all sugar and all chocolate – well, that doesn’t sound good either.

The reason many budgets fail is because people forget to add or are instructed to eliminate the ingredients they enjoy the most. If you invent a cookie that doesn’t have sugar or chocolate chips please let me know 🙂

Budgets are NOT supposed to be TORTURE!

Don’t get me wrong, there may be some slight discomfort, if you have never told yourself NO, you will have to say NO to yourself occasionally. If you are currently spending more than you earn – just like the little kid who eats chocolate until they vomit, you will have to learn to say NO when you just want to eat the whole bag of chocolate chips in one sitting.

This is the other main reason that budgets fail. A baker has to be disciplined enough to know that just because sugar and chocolate are good, it doesn’t mean that they can just add as much as they want. Having the correct amount of each ingredient is the key to great cookies.

Don’t forget you SHOULD add sugar and chocolate to the cookies, it is what makes them good!! Maybe just not the whole bag. 🙂

Find a recipe you like

Creating a budget is a trial and error process. Just like creating a recipe from scratch will take you a few attempts to get it right, a budget is no different. Using someone else’s recipe may give you a head start, but still may need to be tweaked a little to fit your personal preferences (check out How to make a budget our the Real Money Budgeting course for a head start).

Stick with what works

Once you find the recipe that you like, the only way to get those cookies exactly the way you want them is to follow the recipe. Sure, you can bend on the ingredients if you need to – after all they are YOUR cookies. But learn from the pros – cookie companies may spend years or months developing a recipe, but once they find a great recipe that works, they print out a recipe that measures out each ingredient that will yield those great cookies if followed exactly.

Cookies are made for enjoyment

Cookies are baked by someone for someone to enjoy. Budgets are the same, being disciplined to follow the recipe may be a little bit of a challenge, but the rewards are the cookies!

In terms of a budget, the reward is having control over your financial life, rather than letting it control you, telling your money where it should go, rather than being told, watching debts shrink, watching savings increase, and not really having to think much about money. Now those are some good cookies!!

Add some sprinkles to your cookies!

If you would like to add some sprinkles to your cookies you can start with these free budget spreadsheets or you can find a piece of free budgeting software that tastes good!

Related posts:

  1. 9 Creative Ways to Say Thank You
  2. Christian Goal Setting
  3. Do You Spend Like A Millennial?
  4. Our Honest Medi-Share Review after 14 years

About Bob Lotich, CEPF®

Bob Lotich, CEPF® is a Certified Educator in Personal Finance and has over 15+ years experience writing about Biblical personal finance. He is the award-winning author of Simple Money, Rich Life and has been named a top 20 social influencer in personal finance. Check out his on-demand Christian financial class for couples, small groups and churches called True Financial Freedom.

IFCFH Book of the Year
"The best combination of personal finance and the Christian faith that I’ve read"
– James T. (SMRL reviewer)

In this biblically sound and grace-filled money book, you'll discover the NEW rules of money that will transform your financial life. Say goodbye to outdated advice and hello to a simple, automated system that helps you achieve better results with less time and effort.

"The best combination of personal finance and the Christian faith that I’ve read"
Learn more
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Primary Sidebar

Bob Lotich

Hi there! We are Bob & Linda Lotich. Jesus followers, authors, podcasters, and undying fans of Michael Scott.

This site contains the lessons we learned on our journey from being stingy, debt-ridden fools, to being able to reach our biggest financial goal of giving $1 million by age 40, having zero debt & a paid off house by age 31, and peace with money in the process.

Now we share our best lessons with people like you, groups, and churches with our Award-winning book Simple Money, Rich Life and our 6-week video course True Financial Freedom.

Grab our book!

Simple Money Rich Life

Legal Disclaimer

The articles on this site should not be taken as financial advice. Please contact a financial advisor (or coach) for specific advice regarding your situation. Any references to interest rates, giveaways, deals, products, and websites are subject to change without notice. We try our best to keep the information current, but things are always changing so it may be different now than when it was first published. Also, all the pages on SeedTime help us pay the bills by using affiliate relationships with Amazon, Google, eBay and others but our opinions are NEVER for sale. Find out more here.

Footer



SeedTime is a 2x Plutus award winning website.
seedtime money logo



SeedTime BBB Business Review
seedtime instagram seedtime money youtube channel seedtime money twitter with Bob Lotich


Our book Simple Money, Rich Life was named 2022 book of the year!
  • Home
  • About
  • Beliefs
  • Blog
  • Courses
  • Churches
  • Press
  • Shop
  • Affiliates
  • Login

Privacy Policy | Terms | Reviews | Earnings Disclaimer | Contact | 636-344-0438
625 Bakers Bridge Ave Suite 105-134 Franklin, TN 37067
©2007-2025 · SeedTime (Formerly ChristianPF)